THEW BLOG

UAV LIDAR VS. PHOTOGRAMMETRY

Thew Associates UAV LiDAR MissionOver the past few years, unmanned aerial vehicles (UAV’s) have become a fixture in the toolbox of surveying and mapping professionals. Light Detection and Ranging (LiDAR) sensors and digital cameras mounted on UAV’s allow surveyors to gather a tremendous amount of data more efficiently than conventional surveying methods, which have made the technologies very popular. Thew Associates was an early adopter of UAV technology utilizing both LiDAR and photogrammetry technologies and this post aims to provide an overview of the strengths and limitations of both technologies.

How the Technologies Work

LiDAR is an active sensing technology. Simply put, the sensor sends out light pulses and measures the time it takes for the light to return. Points are then processed and classified to create a 3D point cloud of the site. Conversely, photogrammetry is a passive technology.  Digital photographs are collected with a camera mounted on a UAV and a 3D model is derived by stitching together overlapping images through automated detection of common pixels in each image.

Strengths and Limitations of LiDAR and Photogrammetry

LiDAR and photogrammetry each have their best use cases; therefore, the overall project objective will determine which technology is deployed. Terrain, vegetation, and desired deliverables are just a few of the factors that determine which technology is best suited for your project.

Photogrammetry is best utilized when planimetric information is required. LiDAR’s 3D point cloud is more difficult to derive planimetric information from due to the density of the data set (50 – 100 ppsm); however, intensity values and RGB overlay can be used to produce a visually rich image.

One limitation of photogrammetry is that it can only generate points based on what the camera sensor can detect. Therefore, if topographic information is required in areas where there is vegetation growth, a LiDAR survey is the better method. LiDAR pulses can penetrate tree canopies and other vegetative mats where photogrammetry cannot.

Both technologies have limitations when it comes to weather. Ideal weather for UAV photogrammetry data collection is an overcast day with no precipitation and light to no winds. LiDAR, as an active sensor, can be flown day or night but data cannot be collected with any precipitation or high winds.

LiDAR data processing is much more efficient than UAV imagery processing.  Once the trajectory of the UAV has been resolved utilizing post-process kinematic (PPK) algorithms, a three-dimensional LiDAR point cloud can be generated within a few hours, while the stitching together of digital images utilizing software such as Pix-4D can take up to 24 hours for a relatively small site (e.g. 30 acres).  The LiDAR data also provides a much more reliable and robust solution for creating bare earth data set for topographic mapping.

Thew Associates is currently testing the ability to derive planimetric information from a LiDAR data set by increasing the amount of overlap between flight lines and flying multiple missions to densify the data set. 

LiDAR vs. Photogrammetry Point Cloud

 

LiDAR and Photogrammetry Deliverables

Photogrammetry deliverables can include:

  • Orthomosaic
  • RGB point cloud
  • Digital Surface Model (DSM)
  • Digital Terrain Model (DTM)
  • Planimetrics

LiDAR deliverables can include:

  • 3D Point Cloud
  • Digital Elevation Model (DEM)
  • Digital Terrain Model (bare-earth elevation data)
  • Triangulated Irregular Networks (TINs)

Cost

One of the biggest differences between photogrammetry and LiDAR is the equipment costs. At a relatively affordable price, you can enter the photogrammetry market with the purchase of a DJI drone, a camera, and a subscription to a processing software such as Pix4D.

The cost of entry to performing UAV LiDAR missions is much more expensive due to the technology costs of the LiDAR sensor and the combined with a larger drone platform that is needed to carry the heavier sensor.

UAV vs. Manned Aircraft

The evolution of UAV’s in the surveying and mapping industry has not eliminated the need for manned aircraft LiDAR and photogrammetry. Manned aircraft is still more cost-efficient on larger sites (300+ acres) due to flight times and beyond the line of sight regulations for UAV’s.

Conclusion

There are countless individuals and services firms offering UAV based LiDAR and photogrammetry solutions; however, many of those providers are not professional land surveyors.  Regardless of the technology being employed, sound surveying practices continue to be required to ensure the collected data meets the accuracy standards published by the American Society Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing (ASPRS).  There is no substitute for robust quality control and quality assurance procedures including sufficient and accurate ground control, an adequate number of verification shots, and statistical analysis to ensure the integrity of the data set.

If procuring a UAV service firm to prepare topographic or planimetric mapping, ensure that a professional land surveyor is providing oversight for data acquisition and processing.

Williams receives Hydrographer Certification from National Society of Professional Surveyors

Mark Williams, Project Manager with Thew Associates was notified by the National Society of Professional Surveyors (NSPS) and The Hydrographic Surveyors of America (THOSA) that he has met the requirements of the Certification Board to be registered as a Certified Hydrographer.

The program was established in 1981, and is cooperatively administered by the NSPS and THOSA to identify individuals that are qualified to conduct the rigorous hydrographic surveys needed by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and the Office of Coast Survey under the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA). There are approximately 300 individuals who have been certified as meeting the minimum five year experience requirement and core competencies of a professional hydrographer since the program’s inception in 1981.

“We are very proud of Mark’s accomplishment in achieving his goal of becoming a Certified Hydrographer” said James Thew, Principal of Thew Associates. “He has worked diligently to gain the requisite knowledge and experience to meet the NSPS’s and THOSA’s exacting standards to have been selected to sit for the exam.  We are confident that with Mark’s certification and expertise, Thew Associates can continue to grow our Hydrographic Surveying offerings.”

Land

Land Surveying

Water

Hydrographic Surveying

Subsurface

Subsurface Utility Engineering

Laser Scanning

3D Laser Scanning Services

sUAS

Drone Services

Canton

6431 US Hwy 11
Canton, NY 13617

Phone: 315-386-2776 
Fax: 315-386-1012

Utica

9478 River Road
Marcy, NY 13403

Phone: 315-733-7278
Fax: 315-797-1957

Tupper Lake

29 Park Street Suite 3
Tupper Lake, NY 12986

Phone: 315-267-6007

Syracuse

5866 State Route 31 
Cicero, NY 13039

Phone: 315-244-2151

Thew Associates Land Surveyors
Site Design by Coughlin